Smokin' Fattys BBQ Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing the menu at Smokin' Fattys BBQ, a Mexican, Seafood, and Barbeque joint located in Elkhart, IN. This restaurant offers a variety of amenities such as reservations, delivery, takeout, outdoor seating, and is kid-friendly. Customers rave about the smoked chicken wings, smokehouse combo with ribs, pulled pork, brisket, pork belly, and jalapeno cornbread. The sides like coleslaw, campfire beans, elote corn, and Gigi Sue's cabbage are also highly recommended. Their Alabama white sauce, Dr. Pepper barbecue sauce, and sweet barbecue sauce add an extra kick to the dishes. The generous portion sizes, attentive service, and delightful desserts make it a must-visit spot. The ambiance is relaxed, perfect for a casual dinner or watching sports games at the bar. Whether you're a BBQ enthusiast or looking for a unique dining experience, Smokin' Fattys BBQ promises to deliver flavorful dishes and top-notch service.

Let's Get It Started - Pd

Green Salsa

$6.60

Red Salsa

$6.60

Smoked Wings

Smoked chicken wings, available in or pieces.

$0.00

Cam Cam Shrimp

Crispy shrimp tossed in a tangy, spicy sauce, garnished with fresh cilantro and a wedge of lime.

$15.40

Pretzel Bites

Soft pretzel bites served with a creamy cheese dipping sauce.

$11.00

Chori-Queso

Our Signature Queso sauce topped with Fresh Ground Chorizo accompanied with Tri Colored Chips

$13.20

Garlic Cheese Curds

Wisconsion brick garlic cheese curds fried crispy with a sriracha ranch

$12.10

Jalapeno Hushpuppies

Housemade Jalapeno corn bread hushpuppies with a sriracha honey butter schnizzle

$8.80

Brisket Chili

Slow smoked brisket, peppers, onions, tomato & spices

$6.60

Taco Salad

Romaine lettuce, quesco fresco, charred corn, cilantro, avocado, diced tomato, sweet onion & pulled chicken. Served in a crispy tortilla bowl with salsa rojo

$16.50

Brisket Cowboy Salad

hour smoked brisket and applewood smoked bacon on a bed of romaine tossed with smoked gouda, diced tomato, cucumber, charred yellow corn & sweet onion drizzled with sweet BBQ & Ranch

$17.60

Fatman's Caesar

Smoked pulled chicken on a bed of romaine lettuce tossed with applewood smoked bacon, parmesan cheese, hard-boiled egg, croutons & anchovies with Caesar dressing

$16.50

Plain Jane Caesar

Smoked pulled chicken on a bed of romaine with parmesan cheese & croutons with Caesar dressing

$13.20

Cam Cam Shrimp Salad

Crispy shrimp, roasted corn, avocado slices, cherry tomatoes, and mixed greens tossed in a zesty dressing.

$17.60

Salads - Pd

Up In Smoke - Pd

Dr Pepper Ribs

Pork ribs marinated in Dr Pepper, optional sauces include sweet BBQ, mango habanero, Alabama white, and Carolina mustard. No sauce option available.

$16.50

Pork Belly

Succulent pork belly, available in / lb or full lb. Choose from sweet, mango habanero, Alabama white, Carolina mustard BBQ or opt for no sauce.

$0.00

Pulled Pork

hour slow smoked boneless pork shoulder, shredded

$0.00

Brisket Cheese Steak

hour smoked beef brisket, banana peppers, queso cheese, toasted hoagie

$17.60

Apple Bourbon Pulled Pork

Hickory smoked pulled pork, bourbon apple jam, smoked gouda & provolone, toasted brioche, carolina mustard

$16.50

We B Jammin

Two brisket blend smash patties, bacon jam, peanut butter, provolone, onion straws, toasted brioche

$16.50

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Juicy mushroom Swiss burger paired with one choice from options like campfire beans, fries, or house veggies. Option for sub brisket chili or mac & cheese available.

$17.60

Brisket Dipper

Tender brisket in a soft bun, served with choice of side: campfire beans, fries, veggies, salads, or brisket chili among others.

$18.70

Sandwiches - Pd

South Of Rio - Pd

Birria Tacos

Brought North from our friends in Jalisco, Mexico. Smoked & marinated brisket cooked on a flat top in a corn tortilla shell with smoked gouda cheese. Served with consomme dripping sauce

$18.70

Chicken Tinga Tacos

Chicken tinga tacos served with your choice of side: options range from campfire beans to sub brisket chili.

$18.70

Cam Cam Shrimp Tacos

Fried shrimp, lettuce, queso fresco, cilantro & tomato topped with our secret Cam Cam sauce

$18.70

Fried Walleye

Crispy fried walleye fillets served with golden hush puppies, crunchy potato chips, creamy coleslaw, tartar sauce, and fresh lemon wedges.

$27.50

From The Water - Pd

Getting Cheesy - Pd

Butt Mac

Smoked pulled pork butt on a bed of cavatappi noodles tossed in our give cheese blend, finished with crunchy onion straws, drizzled with mango habanero bbq

$16.50

Cheesy Mac

Our five cheese blend tossed with cavatappi noodles

$14.30

Fatty Mac

Crispy pork belly on a bed of cavatappi noodles tossed in our five cheese blend

$16.50

Moo Mac

Smoked brisket and applewood smoked bacon tossed with a five cheese blend on a bed of cavatappi noodles, finished with green onions

$19.80

ALA Pulled Chicken

Pulled chicken with selectable size: / lb or full lb. BBQ options: sweet, mango habanero, Alabama white, Carolina mustard, or unsauced.

$0.00

ALA Pork Belly

Twice smoked pork belly goodness tossed in our house made sweet BBQ

$0.00

ALA Pulled Pork

hour slow smoked boneless pork shoulder, shredded

$0.00

Ala Cart Meats - Pd

Ala Cart Sides - Pd

Campfire Beans

Northern beans, kidney & baked beans slow simmered in BBQ sauce

$4.40

Fries

Golden and crispy, seasoned to perfection.

$4.40

Walleye Chips

$4.40

Smoked Baby Tatos

Smoked yukon gold baby potatoes tossed in olive oil & seasonings. Make them loaded by adding queso and green onion!

$6.60

Gigi Sue's Cabbage

Fresh shredded cabbage lightly sauteed in a butter with applewood smoked bacon & carrots. Served warm

$4.40

Coleslaw

Purple & white cabbage in a pineapple mango vinaigrette with shredded carrots

$4.40

Elote Corn

Charred sweet corn brushed with cilantro lime cream and a dusting of quesco fresco, served warm

$4.40

House Veggie

$4.40

Side Salad

Romaine lettuce with diced tomato, cucumber, croutons & shredded gouda cheese

$5.50

Side Mac & Cheese

Our five cheese blend tossed with cavatappi noodles

$7.70

Side Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce, tangy dressing, Parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.

$5.50

Side Cornbread

Golden, moist cornbread with a slightly crisp edge and tender crumb.

$3.30

Side Mac Sauce

$5.50

Side Queso

$3.30

Side Red Salsa

$2.20

Side Green Salsa

$2.20

Add A Bun

$2.20

Add Veggie Patty

$6.60

Extra Dressing

Choice of Ranch, Bleu Cheese, French, Caesar, or Italian dressing.

$1.65

Extra Chips

$2.75

oz Brisket

Tender, slow-cooked brisket pieces with a smoky flavor and a rich, savory taste.

$6.60

oz Pulled Pork

$5.50

oz Pork Belly

$6.60

oz Shredded Chicken

$4.40

Gluten-Free Bun

$3.30

Kids Chicken Taco

One flour tortilla with shredded smoked chicken, lettuce, tomato & cheese with crinkle fries

$6.60

Kids Mac

Our five cheese blend tossed with cavatappi noodles, served with crinkle fries

$7.70

Kids Quesadilla

A flour tortilla with melted cheese. served with crinkle fries

$6.60

Kids CheeseBurger

A hand pattied brisket burger with fries

$8.80

Kids Menu - Pd

Desserts - Pd

Blackberry Bread Puddin

Rich and moist bread pudding with blackberries, topped with a creamy sauce and garnished with a swirl of whipped cream and a cherry.

$7.70

Peach Cobbler

A warm and comforting dessert with sweet, juicy peaches and a golden crust.

$8.80

Triple Chocolate Layer Cake

Rich, moist chocolate cake layers with a smooth chocolate ganache, topped with chocolate drizzle.

$14.30

Celebration Cheesecake

Layers of creamy cheesecake and fluffy cake, adorned with colorful sprinkles.

$14.30

Carrot Cake

Layers of moist carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, topped with a dollop of whipped cream and chopped pecans, drizzled with caramel sauce.

$14.30

Ice Cream Scoop

$2.20

Banana Pudding

Classic dessert made with ripe bananas, creamy custard, and layers of vanilla wafers.

$9.90

Tres Leche

Moist cake soaked in three milks: condensed, evaporated, and whole milk.

$9.90

Red Velvet

$13.30

Sweet BBQ

$0.50

Mango Habanero BBQ

$0.50

Alabama White BBQ

$0.50

Cam's Carolina Mustard

$0.50

Extra Salad Dressing

$0.50

Extra Sauces - Pd

Features - Pd

Cajun Seafood Boil

Wet, Dry, or extra / lb Crab Legs.

$34.10

Birria Egg Roll

$16.50

Chicken Pot Stickers

$14.30

Gaucho Pub Steak

$25.30

Havana Melt

$16.50

Dragons Breath Ramen

$25.30

Boss Hog Platter

$31.90

Cowboy Dip

Delicately Smoked Salmon, Perfectly Flavored for a Light, Satisfying Treat

$16.50

Soup Of The Day

Chef's choice soup, made fresh daily with the finest ingredients.

$8.80

Busch Chicken

Busch Light beer brined and smoked in house

$16.50

Ribs

Spare ribs, dry rubbed with a slight BBQ glaze

$0.00

Smokehouse Combo

Sliced brisket, pulled pork, ribs, pork belly & jalapeno cornbread hush puppies with choice of two sides

$38.50

Brisket

hour slow smoked USDA prime brisket gently sliced

$0.00

Up In Smoke After Pm - Pd

Ala Carte After Pm - Pd

ALA Ribs

Spare ribs, dry rubbed with a slight BBQ glaze

$0.00

ALA Brisket

hour slow smoked USDA prime brisket gently sliced

$0.00

ALA Busch Chicken

Busch Light beer brined and smoked in house

$9.90